MIB Designer export patch change for brain-dead parsers?

Martin Janzen janzen____pixelmetrix.com
Mon Feb 18 12:37:37 CET 2002


Hi!  I'm wondering whether it'd be possible to get a minor change in
the way in which MIB Designer writes exported MIBs.  The 1.7 version
adds a comment containing the numeric OID value, as follows:

  tspEventPIDBandwidthAboveMaxThreshold NOTIFICATION-TYPE
      OBJECTS      { ... }
      STATUS       current
      DESCRIPTION  "..."
    -- 1.3.6.1.4.1.6768.6.4.5.0.1000 --  ::= { tspEventsV2 1000 }  

That's nice information to have; but I'd prefer to see this:

  tspEventPIDBandwidthAboveMaxThreshold NOTIFICATION-TYPE
      OBJECTS      { ... }
      STATUS       current
      DESCRIPTION  "..."
      ::= { tspEventsV2 1000 }  -- 1.3.6.1.4.1.6768.6.4.5.0.1000 --

Background: Some network management systems I've run into have broken
MIB parsers, which don't seem to be aware that a second "--" is
supposed to terminate a comment.  Therefore, the important bits are
lost, resulting in lots of load errors, frustrated customers, etc.

Yes, I know we should abuse NMS vendors who do this, and so help to
rid the world of this sort of thing; but in the meantime, putting the
comment at the end of the line would ensure that the MIB always works.

Thanks in advance...

--
Martin Janzen
janzen at pixelmetrix.com



More information about the AGENTPP mailing list